Quantcast i24NEWS - EU labelling of Israel settlement products echoes Nazi era: Netanyahu

EU labelling of Israel settlement products echoes Nazi era: Netanyahu

Jewish settlements in east Jerusalem -- such as Har Homa which was originally built in the 1990s -- are considered to be in breach of the Oslo accords by the Palestinians but not by Israel, which does not see east Jerusalem as occupied territory
Ahmad Gharabli (AFP/File)
Netanyahu: 'This is unjust. It is simply a distortion of justice and of logic...it does not advance peace'

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu on Thursday likened the EU parliament's motion to label products from Jewish settlements to the Nazi era.

"We remember history and we remember what happened when the products of Jews were labelled in Europe," the premier said in a statement issued by his office.

In April, France and 15 other European Union countries urged the bloc to clearly label products sold in member countries that originated in Israeli settlements in the Palestinian territories and annexed east Jerusalem and the Golan Heights, all occupied by Israel in the 1967 Six Day War.

"This is unjust. It's a distortion of justice and of logic, not to mention that it does not advance peace," said Netanyahu.

Tzipi Hotovly, Israel's deputy foreign minister, said the Jewish state would not accept "discrimination" between goods produced in different parts of its territory.

"Labelling of products amounts to a boycott," she said, hours after the European parliament voted in favor of a non-binding resolution to label products from Jewish settlements.

Foreign Ministry spokesman Emmanuel Nahshon said that the EU motion was "discriminatory with a sharp smell of boycott," adding that "under the guise of a technical procedure, this is an attempt to force a diplomatic solution instead of encouraging the Palestinians to return to the negotiating table."

"Europe treats Israel with sanctimonious hypocrisy, while it doesn’t raise the issue of similar solutions in Northern Cyprus and Western Sahara."

The EU has consistently condemned Israeli settlement building as a threat to the Middle East peace process through eroding the basis for a future Palestinian state.

Frederick Florin (AFP)The resolution, which passed by 525 votes to 70, calls on EU foreign policy chief Federica Mogherini “to take the lead within the Commission with a view to completing the work on EU-wide guidelines on the labeling of Israeli settlement produce.”

European parliamentarians also called on Mogherini and EU Special Representative Fernando Gentilini to make better use of member states' political and institutional expertise in order to achieve lasting peace between Israel and Palestine.

Preserving the viability of the two-state solution must be an immediate priority for the EU and the international community, the resolution states.

Peace talks between Israel and the Palestinians broke down in April 2014, and few efforts have been made publicly to restart negotiations.

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu stated on Thursday that he was willing to "immediately" resume negotiations with the Palestinians, "with no conditions whatsoever".

He also indicated he wanted increased cooperation with Britain on cyber-security, adding, "if we pull our resources together we can offer a better future and great prosperity."

The resolution also added that parliamentarians want to see an end to the blockade of the Gaza Strip, and its urgent reconstruction following the summer 2014 war and urged the EU and other donors to live up to their promises to the United Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees in the Near East, which has been under serious financial stress.

The vice-chair of the Progressive Alliance of Socialists and Democrats, Victor Boştinaru, said, "no EU funding can be used to directly or indirectly contribute to Israeli settlement construction, which is illegal under international law, or to Israeli activities violating international humanitarian law in the occupied Palestine Territory, while no EU funding to Palestinians can be directly or indirectly diverted to terrorist organizations or activities."

"Arab citizens of Israel have huge potential to play an important role in the peace process, with the joint Arab list as an important actor in the Knesset."

"The growing violence in the whole region generates new security challenges for Israel and further increase the suffering of Palestinians. It also creates shared interests between the Arab states and Israel."

The European Parliament's European United Left/Nordic Green Left group, meanwhile, criticized the resolution saying it"wanted a stronger-worded resolution. For example, we wanted to demand an end to the occupation of Palestine and the release of political prisoners."

"However, one thing on which I think we are all agreed is that the EU should be a dominant political player in the Middle East peace process and advance meaningful initiatives for a comprehensive solution," the chair of the Parliament's delegation to Palestine, Martina Anderson, said.

"We also believe Palestine should be placed under international protection."

The resolution called for the EU Border Assistance Mission to be reactivated "with a more ambitious mandate and adequate means" to play a concrete role in the controlling of the Gaza Strip's borders with both Egypt and Israel.



"Europe treats Israel with sanctimonious hypocrisy, while it doesn’t raise the issue of similar solutions in Northern Cyprus and Western Sahara." But, isn't it hypocrisy for Europe to sanction Russia for occupation yet constantly appease Israel in that regard?

Because Russia invaded another country... Palestine isn't and has never been a country - the land is disputed subject to an international treaty. Big difference

There are only two options to the current situation, which is unique in the whole world - 5 million Jews vote and decide the fate of nearly 5 million non-citizens, all Palestinians. This is the most non-democratic state in the world. Israel must either decide to separate (and get most of the settlers out, except those who are willing to be Palestinian citizens) or annex the territories and make all Palestinians citizens. The current situation is pure apartheid. To accelerate such decisions of Israel, EU should start marking the addresses of all israelis - and those who live over the green line should get Visas, just as their Palestinian neighbors. We will all be surprised to find how much the settlers' numbers have diminished once that demand will come up.

I notice that the EUROPEAN PARLIAMENTARIANS , NEVER MENTIONED EGYPTS ROLE in the "blockade" of Gaza.. Isn't Egypt culpable or what? Egypt has demolished hundreds of homes, and is continuing to do so, digging a huge moat 100 metres wide, filling it with water etc..To stop Gazans entering

into Egypt. No free passage out of Gaza into Egypt, no goods allowed in or out...ERRRRRRRR I think this makes Egypt equally responsible for "BLOCKADING" Gaza. or does it only apply if you are a jewish state? Gaza was under the control of Egypt, who "gave" it to Israel, so legally Gaza belongs to Israel..It is not part of a "MYTHICAL" country tha muslims like to call "palestine" palestine is not mentioned in the bible, or the Koran,Jerusalem is not mentioned in the KORAN, yet is mentioned in the bible hundreds of times..Israel is mentioned in both the Koran and the bible.. So tell me please GOLDBLUM, where does this mythical land of yours get the name !palestine" from..not even an arabic name..THERE is no P in the arabic alphabet..

more nonsense from Farmer..your "MYTHICAL" palestine does not exist it has no borders, no monetary system, no navy, no army, no air force, no passports, nothing, clume.Mafish, zilch. come on Farmer quote for us please from the UN that says "palestine" is a country..oh yes and Gaza is included in your "MYTHICAL" palestine..remember, the Gaza that is occupied by EGYPT AND ISRAEL..or is it just Israel,,if just Israel explain to all your followers on i24news how only Israel is "OCCUPYING" Gaza.. BUT NOT EGYPT????

I am waiting eagerly for your explanation, it should be a good laugh..most of your comments are quite stupid, so we all laugh at you..

Amiram, you do know that Abbas has stated that future Palestinian state will be Jew free right? Now isn't that Apartheid?

Neil Gordon - "Amiram, you do know that Abbas has stated that future Palestinian state will be Jew free right? Now isn't that Apartheid?" When Jewish terrorist militia drove out over 750,000 Arabs from '47 on destroying their villages, was that Apartheid, Neil?

8Previous articleNetanyahu seeks UK support against 'militant Islam'
8Next articleObama says he hopes to meet Netanyahu at UN next month