• Content
  • Menu
  • Footer
  • Sign in
    • Top stories
    • Israel
    • Middle East
    • Israel elections 2026
    • International
    • INNOV'NATION
    • Videos
    • Radio
    • Shows
    • Schedules
    • Channels
    • Profiles
    • English
    • Français
    • عربى
    • עברית
  • Live

  • i24NEWS
  • International
  • Europe
  • UK university compiled 1,465-page surveillance file on pro-Israel student - report

UK university compiled 1,465-page surveillance file on pro-Israel student - report


Royal Holloway monitored a student's movements, restricted his campus access and referred him to counter-terrorism police despite authorities finding no evidence of extremism.

i24NEWS
i24NEWS
7 min read
7 min read
  • UK
  • United Kingdom
  • students
  • pro-Israel rally
  • university
  • campus antisemitism
Google NewsFollow usFollow
The Founder's Building at Royal Holloway, University of London, Surrey, England, February 17, 2015.
The Founder's Building at Royal Holloway, University of London, Surrey, England, February 17, 2015.DAVID ILIFF/Wikimedia Creative Commons

A university in the UK compiled a secret surveillance file on one of its own students that reached nearly 1,500 pages long, according to a Telegraph report on Sunday.

Brodie Mitchell is a student at Royal Holloway University located just outside London.

In September 2025, he attended his university's introductory week, during which students could explore various clubs and organizations based out of the university, where he manned the Conservative Society's stall. He placed a British flag with a Star of David at its center on the stall.

Mitchell was then faced with shouts of "genocide supporter" as well as staring. This eventually escalated into an altercation between him and Huda El-Jamal, president of the university's Friends of Palestine society.


Mitchell alleges that El-Jamal called him a "wannabe jew" and asked where his kippah was, leading Mitchell to begin recording the incident.

Mitchell is not Jewish and responded by asking why she was wearing a tea towel on her head, referring to her keffiyeh. Both sides dispute each other's allegations.

El-Jamal reported Mitchell to the police, leading to a 12-month investigation into an alleged hate crime, which has since been dropped.


Mitchell was suspended from academic classes the next day. He was then found guilty of misconduct by the university a few weeks later at a hearing he boycotted due to being denied the right to legal representation while the university employed its own lawyer.

During his suspension, he was put under what the Telegraph described as "a form of house arrest." He was confined to his room on campus or the dining room four floors below and was not permitted to go anywhere else.

This confinement seems to have included outdoor spaces and even the cafes and libraries on campus, and even after being permitted to leave his room he remained under what Mitchell called "intense supervision."

Even under these restricted conditions his movements on campus were monitored and reported to the university administration. The Telegraph obtained multiple emails detailing his movements on campus, including various sightings.


Even after these conditions were loosened, he was still restricted, only being permitted to purchase food in the cafeteria but not permitted to eat there and he was allowed to do laundry on campus. All other activities had to be done "off campus."

During the suspension, Mitchell was reported to the university administration for attending a Remembrance Sunday church service at the university chapel. The email stated that the only reason he was not removed from the service was because it had already begun by the time they noticed.

Following the nine-week suspension, he returned to his studies. However, the university ordered his lecturers to monitor him and report his behavior to the university on a regular basis, which, according to the Telegraph, was a violation of the university's own policies. Several lecturers objected to this as they saw it as a violation of university policy.

Mitchell, supported by the Free Speech Union, then launched legal action against the university, which was settled out of court by the university in what it called a "gesture of goodwill."

Despite all this, local police continued to investigate him, while the university instructed an outside organization to monitor and report on his internet usage for his comments on the incident.

Mitchell began to receive death threats online after the settlement and spoke out against what he called the "absolute two-tier madness," in reference to a common claim on the British right that policing in the UK is much harsher toward people who express right-wing views than toward those who express left-wing views.

Mitchell called for the deportation of "Pakistani Muslims" who had issued the death threats against him. This comment led the university to convene a panel that decided to report Mitchell to counter-terrorism police under the Prevent Program, aimed at preventing the violent radicalization of young people. The university never told him he had been referred.

In the submission to Prevent, Mitchell's pro-Israel views are mentioned as connected to his comments on the keffiyeh, which the email described as a suspected hate crime.

Furthermore, he was identified as in need of monitoring due to holding Zionist and pro-Israel views despite not being Jewish, with the conclusion that his comments about Pakistani Muslims indicated that he was being further radicalized.

However, the university admitted later in the submission that it had no evidence that he had engaged with extreme groups, with the university's primary concern being "an escalation of tensions" on campus as a result of the keffiyeh comments.

The day after Mitchell was reported to the counter-terrorism program, he attended a demonstration in solidarity with the Jewish community in the Golders Green area of London following the stabbing attack in the area earlier this year. British counter-terrorism police declared the attack a hate crime, but not terrorism, due to the attacker's mental state both before and during the attack.

At the event, Mitchell held a sign saying "Anti-Zionism = Terrorism," while standing in front of British, Israeli, and American flags.

Mitchell's presence at the demonstration was submitted to counter-terrorism police as evidence of his radicalization and as part of seemingly ongoing monitoring.

Two months after the referral an officer at Thames Valley Police said, "There is no evidence to suggest that the subject is developing an extremist mindset in the promotion or advancement of an ideology based on violence, hatred or intolerance."

Another email sent to the university agreed, stating that "There’s no indication that the subject is fascinated with extreme violence, or being radicalized or radicalizing anyone else. The subject hasn’t shown a hatred for women or men which includes wanting to harm them due to their Incel ideology. The subject is not being drawn into terrorism or drawing other people into it, and as such it doesn’t meet the Counter-Terrorism criteria for adoption." The case was closed soon after.

On October 13, local police closed their investigation into Mitchell without ever progressing beyond the initial investigative stage. Police apologized to Mitchell for creating a misleading impression that the investigation had progressed beyond the initial stage.

The files detailing the university's surveillance of Mitchell total 1,465 pages. However, even after the university gave them to Mitchell, a large number remain either wholly or partially redacted, to protect the privacy of the emails' senders and recipients.

The number of pages kept on Mitchell is extraordinary. According to German state archives, the Ministry for State Security, also known as the Stasi, kept an average of 200 pages on people of interest while ordinary citizens had, at most, a couple of pages in their files.

No large UK publishing house want to work with ex-hostage Sharabi on memoir
No large UK publishing house want to work with ex-hostage Sharabi on memoir

Suggested articles

  • Former IRGC commander to address London conference on Islamophobia | i24NEWS
  • 'Antisemitism crosses all boundaries,' review finds rampant antisemitism in English schools | i24NEWS
  • UK equality watchdog questions Green Party over 'Zionism is racism' motion | i24NEWS
This article received 0 comments

Comments

  • News
  • News feed
  • Live
  • Radio
  • Shows
  • Get the Google Play app
  • Get the IOS app

Information

  • i24NEWS EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE
  • i24NEWS PROFILES
  • i24NEWS TV SHOWS
  • Live radio
  • Career
  • Contact
  • Sitemap

Categories

  • Breaking News
  • Israel
  • Middle East
  • Israel elections 2026
  • International
  • INNOV'NATION

Legal

  • Terms of service
  • Privacy policy
  • Advertising Terms and Conditions
  • Accessibility declaration
  • Cookie list

Follow us

  • Subscribe to newsletter